Tuesdays With Dorie: Chipster-Topped Brownies


I like brownies. I love chocolate-chip cookies (most especially ones made from the amazing oatmeal chocolate-chip recipe on the Quaker Oats box). How could I go wrong with this week’s TWD recipe, which combines the two.

I managed.

I made these in a hurry, a couple of hours before #2 Son’s belated 12th-birthday party. He planned it himself; my only job was to provide the food, so I figured this was a perfect opportunity to make this week’s selection. (I also made one of June’s selections, but you’ll have to wait a while to hear about that.)

A lot of people mentioned having trouble spreading the cookie dough over the brownie batter. That wasn’t a problem. The batter stiffened a bit while I was making the dough, and I just used small spoonfuls of dough and smooshed them together.

Then I baked it for 45 minutes, less than the 50 to 55 called for in the recipe, and when I took it out the cookie layer was dark, maybe too dark, and had risen higher than I expected. I stuck a knife in and got just a few streaks of chocolate, just like the recipe says. So I let the brownies cool in the pan. They unmolded fine.

I trimmed off the burnt edges, and they were good. I sliced a couple of rows of bars, and except for a distressing tendency for the cookie layer to crack, all was well. But when I got to the third row brownie batter oozed out, essentially unbaked. I happen to love brownie batter, so I’m perfectly happy to eat it that way, but it felt wrong serving raw eggs to other people’s children.


They ate the edge bars, though, and they seemed quite happy with them. I got only three quotes, though; sorry about that.

Friend #1: I’ve never heard of a cookie being on top of a brownie. I thought it was really yummy!

#2 Son: They were pretty good. The brownie was delicious, but the chocolate chip cookies on top were overly salted and too crunchy and not all that good. [That didn't stop him from scarfing them down.]

Husband: I liked the middle ones better, where the bottom of the cookie layer was still gooey. Overall, I thought they were a little too sweet.


I thought the brownies were pretty good, although too dark for me. I loved the cookies on top. But together, they just weren’t as sublime as I thought they’d be. Oh, well.


Go see what all the other TWD bloggers did with this recipe, and if you want to try it for yourself, buy Baking: From My Home to Yours by Dorie Greenspan or visit Supplicious; Beth is the blogger who chose this recipe for us this week.

11 Responses to “Tuesdays With Dorie: Chipster-Topped Brownies”

  1. pamela Says:

    Sorry you had some baking issues with these. They do look wonderful, though. And serving them at the party was a really good idea.

  2. Teanna Says:

    Yeah, these didn’t knock my socks off, either! They look great, though! Your cookie layer looks perfect!

  3. isa Says:

    Mine were a little gooey in the middle either. Sorry that your brownies didn’t turn out well. They looks wonderful.

  4. Kim Says:

    So sorry the center didn’t set. I loved them. I love the quotes. Especially about the cookies being too salty. I’m sure he said that while shoving it in his mouth.

  5. chocolatechic Says:

    I didn’t have any problem spreading the cookies, I had problems getting the done.

  6. Lori Ann Says:

    Your brownie certainly looks sublime! I like the edges best because I like crunchy. I like the quotes you share, your #2 son has quite the palate.

  7. dharmagirl Says:

    these edge pieces look wonderful! i’m sorry these weren’t as spectacular as you thought:(

  8. Judy Says:

    Your brownies look delicious even with the issues. My brownie layer stiffened up as well while I was making the cookie topping. I think that helped keep the top layer from sinking

  9. Kaitlin Says:

    It’s frustrating when a recipe doesn’t turn out as promised, especially with a recipe that sounds so good. I know you weren’t the only one who had issues getting this recipe to bake properly.

  10. Leslie Says:

    They didn’t thrill me either (but mine had a ooze leakage issue that doomed them to the trash can). At least we have another recipe for next week!

  11. Margot Says:

    Your layers look great! I thought spreading the cookie dough would be the biggest problem, too, but it was definitely the uneven baking. Did you actually have a birthday the month the perfect party cake was selected? I had been hoping it would coincide with my birthday and it didn’t.

Leave a Reply

We’re All Foodies Here