Tuesdays With Dorie: World Peace Cookies

wpcookies3

Dorie Greenspan has changed my life. I love chocolate candy, but I’ve never been a huge fan of chocolate cake or cookies (although I love brownies; go figure). But these cookies have changed all that.

I have made World Peace cookies before. And as we’re trying to cut back on the sugar and fat around here, if this were any other recipe in the book I’d probably have gone back to old photos and written the post from memory.

But this is not any other recipe.

These are, bar none, the best cookies in the world. Nay, in the universe. Dare I say in the megaverse?

I love these cookies.

But even though I’ve made these three or four times already, I tried two new techniques this time. Both were brilliant, if I do say so myself.

First, I shaped each half (well, actually, quarter; I doubled the recipe) of the dough into a rough log and wrapped it in plastic wrap before final shaping. Boy, did that made things easier. Then I slit a paper towel roll (as suggested by Dorie herself) down the side and used that to make sure the dough logs were the right diameter for their whole length. So much neater!

I also baked half a dozen of these little darlings before refrigerating the dough (and after it had been sitting on the counter for an hour or so). They flattened in the oven much more than the refrigerated ones, but they were scrumptious. I think I like them even better that way. (Who would have thought that was possible?) They were thin, but soft and chewy like the best chocolate chip cookies. I was going to save one so I could report on how it was the next day, but I couldn’t resist. Sorry.

wpcookies1

The next afternoon I baked the rest, and surprise! They were just as thin and chewy after having been refrigerated for 20 hours or so. In the past, my World Peace cookies have always come out almost like chocolate shortbread. This time they were completely different — if I’d had these somewhere else, I wouldn’t even have recognized them as the same recipe. And I have to say, we like them even better this way.

There were two very small differences in the ingredients this time around: First, #1 Son had been cooking all day on the day I made the dough, and he had left almost three sticks of butter out softening for me. I needed 22 tablespoons, but the nearly full stick had seven rather than six tablespoons left, and, throwing caution to the wind, I tossed the whole thing in there. So that’s essentially an extra half-tablespoon of butter for the basic recipe. And then when I was adding the dry ingredients, I spilled some — no more than two tablespoons or so.

So there you have it: a tiny bit more butter, a tiny bit less flour. A totally different cookie. Fun with chemistry!

I have two photos here to demonstrate the huge difference. The top one comes from the lovely blog She’s Becoming Doughmesstic; thank you, Susan, for so generously allowing me to borrow it. Mine have always looked just like that. The one on the bottom is, of course, this batch.

susanwpcookie

wpcookies4

I made about six dozen of these. By the time we got to the party I made them for, it was down to four dozen or so. Fifteen minutes after I laid them out on the table, there were only crumbs.

I didn’t interview people at the party, but here’s the family:

Husband: I actually liked them better before, when they were more shortbready. They were more special that way. They were good this time, too, though.

#1 Son: The added butter and reduced flour gave them a beautifully crumbly texture without being as dry as I’ve found some past batches. [We're planning to send him to military school for suggesting that these cookies have even been anything but fabulous.]

#2 Son: They were just as delicious as they were last time, if not more so. They were especially good with the ice cream [coffee and vanilla]. I think they would have been even better if you’d used the 72% chocolate. [I debated between regular bittersweet and the crazy dark stuff, and I went with the regular. I'm a milk chocolate gal!]

wpcookies5

Go read 300 other bloggers raving about these cookies. And if you don’t already own Baking: From My Home to Yours, buy it. While you’re waiting for the chance to get to the store or for the book to come in the mail, you can find the recipe at Cookbookhabit. In the name of all that is chocolatey, make these cookies.

wpcookies2

24 Responses to “Tuesdays With Dorie: World Peace Cookies”

  1. pamela Says:

    They look great either way. I like that you baked them after they had been sitting. I know I would enjoy them like that, too!

  2. Jennifer Says:

    I LOVE these cookies…they are SO delicious! You did a beautiful job!

  3. chocolatechic Says:

    I loved these cookies.

    I made mine a bit bigger.

  4. Susan Says:

    Thanks for the credit – but now I am going to be forced to try the cookies YOUR way! They sound wonderful, and look great too!

  5. Leanne Says:

    I am not a big fan of all chocolate cookies but boy did these cookies change my mind.

  6. Megan Says:

    Quite the group of discriminating cookie eaters in your house. I love it!

  7. AmyRuth Says:

    You have to love the charm of #2 son! What a smart boy. he he This cookie truly is the best cookie ever and I’ve tasted many. We are watching the calories around here as well. World Peace cookies are worth the calories. Yep, the extra time on the treadmill is worth it.
    AmyRuth

  8. Katrina Says:

    Awesome. Good to know. Great photos!

  9. Babette Says:

    Lovely with extra butter, less flour, held in fridge, eaten warm, eaten cold…These are just yum…

    b

  10. Teanna Says:

    Oooh, I am going to have to try those changes! Your description has me sold on your version! These really were great cookies!

  11. Leslie Says:

    What a discriminating family to bake for! I would love to get this kind of analytical, objective feedback (M thinks everything I make is the best thing he’s ever tasted, even when it’s not). I love how your cookies look and the idea of using 72% makes me swoon.

  12. Michelle from Baken Says:

    Interesting point about the extra butter and less flour.

    You’re cookies look like they would be amazing sandwiched with vanilla ice cream.

  13. Di Says:

    Interesting. I love trying to figure out why things turn out the way they do. Your cookies look great.

  14. Margaret Says:

    Great looking cookies. Doesn’t matter if they look different as long as they taste GOOD!!!!

  15. Sugar B Says:

    Hi Lillian!

    Yours look really good. I would consider mine “rustic”-looking. ;)

    Thanks for checking out my blog!

  16. Steph Says:

    I know exactly what you mean about cookies changing texture the next day, these stayed exactly the same as they did the day before. I think I’m going to really try and underbake them more next time. I’m afraid ofa dding butter and having the cookies melt into a puddle like the brown sugar pecan cookies I made. Your cookies look extra decadent!

  17. carmen Says:

    Great pics! Your cookies look delicious – I love this recipe too. Sounds like it was a hit with your family!

  18. Elizabeth - Cake or Death? Says:

    I think you’re right–these are the best cookies in the world! I enjoyed reading about your experiments and variations.

  19. Lynne Says:

    Great post on the World Peace cookies. You are lucky to have such a knowledgeable panel of advisers in your household.

  20. Garrett Says:

    It’s really amazing how the smallest of changes can alter a dish when you’re baking. It’s even more amazing when I see people who are able to bake perfectly without really measuring things out…I suppose it just gets to the point that you gain so much experience that you just get an eye for it. At least they still taste great though!

  21. CB Says:

    I am not a big fan of choco-on-choco cookies either. But I totally loved these cookies. Go figure! I think thats why I like baking. The science nerd in me gets to have fun experimenting AND reap the rewards of the outcome too! Win win! Glad you and the family enjoyed the recipe!
    Clara @ iheartfood4thought

  22. LyB Says:

    Now I totally have to try them this way. They look fantastic. :)

  23. Jacque Says:

    Yay! Butter to the rescue! LOL, they sound yummy… I might have to try a little more butter next time.

    I’m glad you liked them.

  24. Confectiona’s Realm » Blog Archive » Tuesdays With Dorie: Espresso Chocolate Shortbread Cookies Says:

    [...] for my older son’s going-away party, and they had some competition. I also made Dorie’s World Peace cookies (with a combo of chocolate chips and mint chips — they were beyond delicious), Ben made some of [...]

Leave a Reply

We’re All Foodies Here